Exploring the event when the moon ‘turned itself inside out’ billions of years ago

Exploring the event when the moon ‘turned itself inside out’ billions of years ago
(Left) a detailed image of the moon (Right) Schematic illustration with a gravity gradient map of the lunar nearside and a cross-section showing two ilmenite-bearing cumulate downwellings from lunar mantle overturn. (Image credit: NASA/Adrien Broquet/University of Arizona & Audrey Lasbordes)

Key Takeaways:

  1. The moon’s formation, estimated at around 4.5 billion years ago, followed a violent collision between Earth and another celestial body, leading to the ejection of material that eventually formed the moon.
  2. Researchers from the University of Arizona’s Lunar and Planetary Laboratory propose various scenarios for the moon’s formation, likening it to a complex narrative akin to a “choose-your-own-adventure” story.
  3. Analysis of moon rock samples suggests a period of significant upheaval, potentially resulting in the moon “flipping inside out,” which could explain peculiarities in its composition.
  4. The presence of titanium-rich volcanic rocks primarily on the moon’s near side poses a mystery, with theories suggesting rapid formation of the moon leading to the initial presence of a molten magma ocean that solidified over time.
  5. Data from NASA’s Gravity Recovery and Interior Laboratory (GRAIL) mission supports hypotheses regarding the migration of dense materials within the moon’s interior, shedding light on its geological evolution and providing insight into future lunar exploration missions.

Approximately 4.2 billion years in the past, the moon underwent a remarkable transformation, reshaping its surface into the familiar sight we recognize today.

According to the consensus among most scientists, the moon came into existence roughly 4.5 billion years ago through a cataclysmic event when a large celestial body collided with Earth. This collision ejected molten material into space, which eventually coalesced to form our moon.

However, the subsequent evolution of the moon post-collision has been likened to a complex narrative akin to a “choose-your-own-adventure” story by a group of researchers from the Lunar and Planetary Laboratory (LPL) at the University of Arizona.

These researchers propose that there were numerous plausible trajectories the formation of Earth’s moon could have followed, ultimately culminating in the present-day moon-Earth system. While the team presents its own theories regarding the pivotal events that shaped the moon, they acknowledge the multitude of interpretations within the scientific community.

For instance, analysis of rock samples retrieved during the Apollo missions suggests a period when the moon experienced a significant upheaval, potentially causing it to undergo a dramatic inversion.

This phenomenon, if substantiated, could offer a solution to a longstanding mystery concerning the moon’s composition.

“Our research indicates that the moon underwent a literal inversion of its structure,” remarked Jeff Andrews-Hanna, an associate professor at LPL. “However, the scarcity of physical evidence complicates our understanding of the precise sequence of events during this crucial phase of lunar history, leading to considerable divergence in the details of proposed theories.”

One puzzling observation involves the presence of titanium-rich volcanic rocks primarily concentrated on the near side of the moon. The University of Arizona team postulates that the moon experienced rapid formation, resulting in the initial presence of a molten magma ocean covering its entirety. As this ocean cooled and solidified, it gave rise to the moon’s outer layers, including its mantle and crust. Yet, beneath the surface, the nascent moon remained in a state of flux.

According to models of lunar formation, the residual remnants of this primordial lunar ocean crystallized into dense materials, including ilmenite—a mineral abundant in iron and titanium. Due to their greater density compared to the underlying mantle, these heavy minerals would have induced gravitational instabilities, causing them to sink deeper into the moon’s interior.

“We hypothesize that these dense materials would have gradually descended into the moon’s depths, forming sheet-like structures within its interior,” explained Weigang Liang, the lead researcher and former doctoral candidate at LPL.

(Left) a “traditional” lunar view (center) mare region is surrounded by a polygonal pattern of linear gravity anomalies (right) blue patches indicate vestiges of dense material that sank into the interior of the moon. (Image credit: Adrien Broquet/University of Arizona)

Nevertheless, questions persist regarding the manner in which these materials migrated within the moon’s interior and ultimately surfaced on its near side.

“Various models offer conflicting interpretations, each bearing profound implications for our understanding of the moon’s geological evolution,” remarked Adrien Broquet, a scientist at the German Aerospace Center and co-lead author of the study.

One proposed model, developed by Nan Zhang of Peking University, suggests that a colossal lunar impact could have displaced a layer of titanium-rich material beneath the moon’s crust, subsequently leading to its accumulation on the near side. This material would have then descended into the moon’s interior, leaving behind dense titanium deposits.

“The alignment between our model predictions and observed gravity anomalies on the moon is striking,” Andrews-Hanna noted. “These anomalies hint at the presence of dense material lurking beneath the lunar surface.”

To validate their hypotheses, the research team analyzed data from NASA’s Gravity Recovery and Interior Laboratory (GRAIL) mission, which mapped variations in the moon’s gravitational field. Their findings corroborated simulations of ilmenite layer distribution, providing further insight into the migration of these materials.

Moreover, the team deduced that the inversion of the moon’s structure occurred prior to the formation of large, ancient impact basins, suggesting a causal relationship between the two phenomena. This chronological alignment implies that the lunar inversion may have triggered subsequent volcanic activity across the moon’s surface.

This research sheds light on the enigmatic features of the moon, including the formation of the Oceanus Procellarum region—a dark expanse visible from Earth—and the asymmetrical distribution of rare elements such as titanium and thorium.

Artist’s concept of NASA’s Grail mission. Grail’s twin spacecraft are flying in tandem orbits around the moon to measure its gravity field in unprecedented detail.  (Image credit: NASA/JPL)

“The moon’s earliest history is encoded beneath its surface, awaiting discovery through a combination of theoretical models and empirical data,” Andrews-Hanna remarked. “This revelation underscores the dynamic nature of celestial bodies and the importance of unraveling their evolutionary narratives.”

Looking ahead, future missions, such as NASA’s Artemis III, hold the promise of further elucidating the moon’s mysteries and deepening our understanding of its complex evolution.

“When Artemis astronauts embark on their historic journey to the moon, they will confront a celestial neighbor whose secrets are gradually being unveiled,” Liang concluded. “This new era of lunar exploration will undoubtedly reshape our perception of Earth’s closest companion.”

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments